Mary Braybrooke spoke about the value of restorative justice in her work as a magistrate. ‘Through facilitating a meeting between a criminal and a victim one can achieve a deeper sense of justice for the victims and often it turns out that the criminal is a victim too. It can produce apologies from the criminal and forgiveness from the victim, but sometimes it is just too hard to forgive. It is becoming quite an in thing and is even finding itself being used in the workplace to resolve issues there.’
Rania Gendy, a peace activist shared from the floor how only two weeks before the conference she was so disheartened and she was wondering if individual effort in peace activities made any difference at all to bringing peace in the world. Then she added, “ having spent one day together with people who care and are finding ways of reconciling, and listening to Manal’s story, I know each individual’s effort counts for something…..and am so happy and encouraged and congratulate UPF and everyone for such a wonderful day giving hope to everyone.
Vanessa Edwards, shared a beautiful story about a female offender who transformed her life by following Vanesa’s advice and taking a decision to look at life differently. About the day as a whole Vanessa said, “ It was such a nice and bright day for such a serious topic. Well done everyone!”
“For me the whole day was extremely worthwhile and meaningful,” Margaret said, “ as shared by many, the personal stories touched everyone’s heart. The most amazing story being that of Manal and Barbara. Manal spoke reflectively about how she lost fifteen members of her family in the last Israeli attack on Gaza. Her courage to turn her grief into reconciliatory efforts for peace was so moving. Barbara, a Jewish neighbour, reached out to Manal to console her in her hour of need. Manal embraced Barbara’s offer and they started out together to work for peace. Participants could observe how the story was told with grief and yet with much love, understanding, warmth and a deep feeling of reconciliation, instead of anger, resentment and an unforgiving attitude. Manal told us all that, ‘It is hard, but there is a great feeling of overcoming anger when you forgive. It is still not possible to forget. One cannot forget nieces and nephews, one of whom was only 2 yrs old, who lost their lives for no reason! In fact I think it is good to forgive but always remember the victims.’ ”
Brenda Hodgson, who led the morning meditation, later commented that “There wasn’t a dry eye when Manal Timraz spoke from the heart about her reconciliatory attitude to do something about her grief.”
Rev Braybrooke said that "seeing the value and impact of sharing personal stories I am encouraged to recommend that we consider spending another day possibly in autumn to hear other stories that have transformed lives through people’s attitudes." This was received enthusiastically by the participants demonstrating the inspiration of the day.
Note: Imam Sajid and Rev Braybrooke have both written conference papers and books on the topic. This is one of the reasons why the conference attracted and inspired around 80 people throughout the day. The participants were not only from our Universal Peace Federation Community Cohesion and Interfaith Working Groups but also from the wider network of Ambassadors for Peace.
Nine stages of Forgiveness read by Rev. Dr. Marcus Brybrooke
Some writers have identified nine stages in the act of forgiving.
- THE INJURED PARTY experiences negative feelings of anger and rage. Important that these are recognised and not repressed.
- THE INJURED PARTY demands justice and punishment, at least recognition by others that they have been wronged.
- THE INJURED PARTY recognises that the wrong he or she has suffered is still damaging his or her life, indeed making the person a double victim, injured by the wrong and also by his or her own bitterness.
- The vital change is when THE INJURED PARTY looks beyond himself and thinks about the wrong doer, recognising that he or she is also a human being. It maybe that THE INJURED PARTY feels there is a religious obligation to forgive. “Forgiveness” it has been said “is a matter of a willed change of heart.
- There may be a personal claim on THE INJURED PARTY, in that the WRONG DOER is a brother or a close relation and if THE INJURED PARTY pursues the vendetta it will upset their mother.
- Stage 4 and 5 are about feeling one ought to forgive; stage 6 is a wanting to forgive. Genuine sympathy for the wrong doer.
- “Reframing” can help. One begins to separate the wrong doer from the wrong he has done. Perhaps with their upbringing or situation, they are not really to blame.
- THE INJURED PARTY may try and show some public sign of forgiveness, perhaps a letter or a desire to meet.
- Finally, THE INJURED PARTY’S negative feeling have been overcome and replaced with positive emotions toward the WRONG DOER. Of course the WRONG DOER may be unknown or not about, but sometimes, as in Restorative Justice, THE INJURED PARTY and WRONG DOER meet and form a relationship.